05/21/2012
07:59 PM
Like the Burgers, Love the Shakes
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 4 of 5 stars
The line of this place looked intimidating; but it moves quickly. Burgers are very juicy and flavorful and the shakes are a must, very thick and with strong deep flavor.
The place gets very...
05/21/2012
03:49 PM
Fab burgers and great value
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 5 of 5 stars
We stopped here for a quick bite and loved it. We went for the standard burger and weren't disappointed, certainly the best counter service burger we had on our trip. The sauce is something else!
05/18/2012
09:33 AM
Average
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 3 of 5 stars
If you don't have too high expectations, this place could be great.
05/16/2012
02:50 PM
good food but nothing that special
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 3 of 5 stars
the line is always long but goes pretty fast. the burgers are good but nothing that special.
05/14/2012
11:48 PM
For you west coasters... In & Out is better!
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 3 of 5 stars
I was lucky I got there at 11:30 AM with no line in front of me. I ordered a small Shack burger, fries and a vanilla custard. At first bite, the burger was too salty and the buns were ordinary. The...
05/14/2012
08:49 PM
Busy!
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 4 of 5 stars
The line-up was crazy, but the shakes were worth it. Go and try it if the line isn't out of the building. Worth the time and the prices are nothing terrible.
05/13/2012
07:49 PM
No great shakes
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 3 of 5 stars
Wasn't as awesome as we had expected. Burgers were ok, not a lot of options for toppings. Staff were friendly and service was fairly quick considering the line.
05/13/2012
04:32 PM
Long lines, but good burgers
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 4 of 5 stars
There always seems to be a line outside this joint, but that's because for midtown Manhattan, it's hard to find a meal that is this cheap and this tasty.
05/13/2012
01:43 PM
No long line for a frozen custard!
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 5 of 5 stars
Very tasty food, friendly staff and a nice buzz about the place.
05/13/2012
11:58 AM
Long Line but worth the wait
TripAdvisor traveller rating: 5 of 5 stars
The line was super long (out the door) but it was totally worth the wait. This was right around the corner from where we stayed and it was worth it!