05/11/2012
08:00 AM
great lobster roll...cute place!
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
The name says it all...it's an adorable, tiny place that's a bit "campy!"....and has great fish! Two of us had the lobster roll, cooked & seasoned perfecty (not too much mayo) with some really...
04/16/2012
09:53 AM
good food, poor hostess = avg
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 3 of 5 stars
The food was great. We started with smoked trout and beet and goat cheese salads. My friend ordered theArtic Char and I had the cod sandwich with fries. Both were very good. Lots of flavor, fresh...
04/09/2012
02:23 AM
Best lobster roll in NYC.
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
I'm a regular at Mary's when in New York and love everything about it: the quaint decor, the very nice service, but especially the fantastic and innovative food at very reasonnable prices for New...
03/05/2012
02:04 PM
East coast cuisine done without flair
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 3 of 5 stars
Mid-week lunch. Shredded beets with dill was well presented although dressing too tart for a dish that ought to be about sweetness. Clams on a roll with celery root remoulade quite bland and...
03/04/2012
12:28 PM
Outstanding lobster rolls
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
Get there early or you will wait and bring cash as they don't take credit cards. The staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating.
02/21/2012
02:34 PM
Great small place...but be ready to wait
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars
Delicious seafood, fresh, just a tad pricey.
Go early, get your name on the list, go have a drink and let them call you when table is ready.
It's small and only holds about 20-25 people...
01/16/2012
05:40 AM
Lobster roll is great.
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars
I've been here a few times now over my past few visits to NYC. The lobster roll is great. Tiny place, very tight seating and high turnover of customers - you don't want to linger when there is a queue...
07/20/2011
06:13 AM
Lobster roll....nuff said!
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars
I've been around the world in search for the best Lobster Roll and this restaurant has one of the best. You only go here for the food and not the ambiance. Service is good. Make sure you have...
06/17/2011
05:43 AM
Overpriced, Overcrowded, Arrogant.
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 1 of 5 stars
Overcrowded. You know something’s wrong when the tables are so close that they need to be pulled into the center of the room to get up. Good if you want to hear every word of your neighbor’s...
05/30/2011
10:10 AM
Good food. TERRIBLE service.
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 1 of 5 stars
The food was good, but not astounding. Lobster was fresh and well cooked, a pleasure to eat.
HOWEVER. The aim of any restaurant should be to welcome guests, make them feel at home and give them an...