05/09/2012
02:35 PM
Best smoked fish in uptown Manhattan
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
The smoked rainbow trout was amazing. Instead of lox on a bagel, get the western novie on a bagel. So good!
05/09/2012
07:24 AM
Best Smoked Fish Anywhere
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
The quality and variety are excellent. Where else do you get smoked Sturgeon? The countermen are friendly and make a great experience. It's tight quarters but it's a New York scene. You can get the...
05/07/2012
08:39 AM
Watery Matzo Ball Soup
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars
On my first visit I had a pastrami sandwich, which I really enjoyed. Second visit not as good--while the matzo ball was good the broth was very watery. Also had potato pancakes and they were good. My...
04/09/2012
04:57 AM
Sturgeon King! Says it all. If it's smoked fish it's nonpareil!
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
Periodically I need a fix and this "pusher" has the best.
04/08/2012
09:36 PM
Great New York Deli...Loved It
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
We were in New York City for a few days and made a special trip to come to Barney Greengrass'. It was worth it! We loved the atmosphere, waiter and food. We enjoyed it a lot.
03/27/2012
08:56 AM
The best herring salad on an everything bagel....and David Blaine's card tricks
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
Difficult to review an iconic eating establishment like Barney Greengrass. All the hype. The high prices and long lines. In this case, it is worth all the hassle, the high prices, the tight quarters....
03/26/2012
12:55 PM
Real NYC Deli!
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars
We have made this our Christmas Day tradition. Best place for getting a feel for a real NYC deli. Everything is delicious, the bagels and Lox are my favorite. My husband usually has the scambled...
03/23/2012
10:13 AM
THE BEST BAGELS and LOX in the USA
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
I absolutely loved this place! I know it's all in the water....as we have a new york bagel in chicago but barney's is the absolute best place! Lots of celebs go here with their families...and I came...
03/22/2012
01:30 PM
Expensive, but authentic atmosphere...okay food.
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 3 of 5 stars
If you want to step back in time and visit an authentic NYC deli that has remained relatively untouched in 50 or so years, Barney Greengrass is for you. The atmosphere is the quintessential NYC deli...
03/19/2012
07:09 AM
A gem on the UWS
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
A gem on the UWS. Consistently terrific food and service. The house made gravlox is freaking amazing. I had a side of it with some excellent scrambled eggs and onions and a bialy last week, and it was...