05/22/2012
03:29 PM
A lovely, Grand Dame Hotel
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
Was a little hesitant when I read the other reviews but I was surprisingly impressed. The lobby is bright and elegant, but also comfortable. We got an upgrade to a suite - the room was large, clean,...
05/21/2012
10:58 AM
Englishman in NYC
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 3 of 5 stars
Very happy with the location, the rooms and bed very comfortable and, at least the two I stayed in, bigger than usual for a Manhattan hotel. (I have stayed in, or at least been offered, some real...
05/18/2012
08:35 PM
Nice hotel, but a bit underwhelming
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 3 of 5 stars
Not in the best location, and no room service after 11. The lobby is pretty, and the rooms are nice.
05/18/2012
12:41 PM
Great location, Solid property, Decent Value, Typical Older NYC property but with Style
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars
Have stayed here many times, before and after becoming a "Marriott" hotel. The location really is quite good if you want to see the sights - and not too far from the great neaighborhoods of...
05/17/2012
12:03 PM
Great Hotel, Great Location, Great Service
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 4 of 5 stars
I stayed at this hotel for a week whilst in New York and extremely happy with my selection. I was initially worried after reading negative feedback on Trip Advisor so I thought it was important to...
05/14/2012
04:37 PM
Strike 5, you're OUT!
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 1 of 5 stars
Went for the weekend with another couple. Hubby & I went to check in at the front desk, the desk clerk said she "couldn't help us" then took the next person after us! I went back to her and said, "I...
05/11/2012
10:51 PM
Best Service, great location
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
We booked several rooms for our daughter's wedding and could not have been happier! Location is great, especially walking distance to one of my favorite casual eating spots, Penelope's. There's a...
05/11/2012
08:25 PM
Beware of Rooms That Need Repair!
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 2 of 5 stars
Once you get past the pleasant two story attractive lobby, it's hard to find anything positive to say other than Gramercy Park area is a great location for restaurants and offers a quiet ...
05/09/2012
06:48 PM
Nice NYC Hotel
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 5 of 5 stars
The Carlton Hotel in NYC gives you the feel of and old 1920's look in the lobby and bar area. The rooms are typical NYC, meaning they are a bit tight but have all the essentials and are elegant. The...
05/08/2012
11:47 AM
Don't "Ask Carlton" - He's Obviously Getting Too Old To Care!!!
TripAdvisor traveler rating: 2 of 5 stars
The motto of this hotel is, "Just Ask Carlton" . . .well, I soon found out that Carlton could care less. Between a delivery mix-up, the incessant dog barking beside my hotel room at 6:00am and the...